Freddie Economist Speaks at Five Star
Nothaft warned that we are not at the “trough” of the current crisis yet, but that we are getting close. “The housing contraction has still a bit further to go,” Notaft said, noting that recession risks are still highly elevated and credit quality is continuing to deteriorate. All in all, Nothaft said, we can expect slowed growth for the balance of this year.
We are starting to see a recovery in housing starts and existing home sales, Nothaft said. But, he cautioned, nationally home prices are still receding and are expected to continue an overall decline into 2009.
As we have consistently seen over last year and half, quarter after quarter, Nothaft said, creditors across the lending community – primary and secondary – are tightening their lending standards and criteria for all lines of business. Because of recent turmoil and institution shake-ups, Nothaft warned, we can expect banks to become even more cautious with lending standards, without any sign of letting up anytime soon. With that in mind, Nothaft said to expect the lending crunch to continue through 2009.
Nothaft did note a few hopeful market signs. Over the past year or so, he said, mortgage rates have consistently climbed upward, but within just the last month, we have begun to see them drop. A drop in mortgage rates will significantly help with the housing market's recovery, said Nothaft.
Another bit of good news for lenders, Nothaft said, is that Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae have and will continue to make sure that there is credit readily available. In the past year and a half, Nothaft explained, we've seen a dramatic shift in the financing of mortgage loans. While private-label mortgage backed securities (MBS) virtually disappeared as the subprime crisis hit and defaults began to soar, Nothaft said, security issuance by Freddie and Fannie has remained steady, and will continue.
Single-family home building hit a record high in 2005, but fell more than 60% since then – the biggest crash in U.S. history, Nothaft said. Likewise, existing home sales are down sharply since the 2005 home building peak, he added.
What this has left us with, Nothaft said, is a large inventory overhang in most regional markets, primarily the result of 2005-2006 over-building. “We've got about a three million inventory surplus now,” Nothaft said. In normal market conditions, that number is two million, Nothaft explained, so we've got about a million excess in terms of the number of houses on the market. Housing markets are not going to improve until we work down that excess inventory, Nothaft said.
For this reason, Nothaft said he does not expect a national recovery in home prices until 2010. House price declines have been widespread and severe in some large markets from the second quarter of 2007 to the second quarter of 2008.There are regional, local markets that might have appreciation, but the national metric will continue to decline through 2009, Nothaft said. In addition, Nothaft noted, the time a home is on the market has risen dramatically in most metro areas.
Nothaft said though, that he does expect mortgage originations to pick up over the next year. In fact, he said, lower mortgage rates in just the last month have already begun to trigger increased activity.
Nothaft also said that he expects mortgage sector job losses for 2008. He noted that about 150,000 jobs have been lost in the mortgage business just over the past two years.
Nothaft concluded, “We still have some bad news ahead of us – more foreclosure and more defaults. It's going to get worse before it gets better.” Nothaft added though, that by the latter part of next year, he expects we'll start to see definitive signs of a modest recovery.



